The next time insomnia hit and I decided to try to chase it with musings, I began to imagine how things might have been different in the past. A wise professor once told me that all decisions must be forward facing, that you can't look back and wish you had known then what you know now. It's a waste of emotional energy. You will never know then what you know now. You just have to do the best to make each decision with what you know at the time.
The thing is...There are plenty of decisions I made in my past, where I made the best choice available to me with my knowledge and understanding at the time. But there are plenty of others wherein I chose poorly with the knowledge I had available at that time. It's not that I know better now, but that I knew better and should have chosen more wisely then.*
Orientation
I should have gone to orientation. This one definitely falls under the "I didn't know better" category. But I should have known better. Not because of myself, but because someone should have made sure I knew better. See previous rant.
Editing
I went to BYU with the intention of being an English major, although I was officially undeclared. Unlike my husband-hunting roommate, I kicked ass at English. Which ended up being a problem. My first grammar course, required for the major, was too easy, so I dropped it. I did not know I could test out of the class and continue in the major. I could have still gone into editing. I ended up loving Sociology, but not majoring in English feels like a choice that was made for me, not something I chose to do. Maybe I could have double majored.
Going Home
My mom wanted me to go home for the summer after freshman year. She wanted to make things right with us. It felt like the right thing to do, to accept the proffered olive branch. But I should have just visited. I was expected to get a job, despite not having access to a vehicle. There was nothing in walking distance. I don't know what she thought I would do. Instead I slept odd hour and succumbed to depression. My mom likes to blame my nightmares on Kevin dumping me the first time; but, one, I dumped him; and, two, the nightmares started when I went back home. It's been almost nineteen years of nightmares since.
I should have stayed in Provo and gotten a full-time job on campus. I would have been better off financially, socially, and emotionally.
Withdrawing
This one is a big one. I did not know that you could withdraw from a class after the drop deadline at the beginning of the semester. Tuition would have still been forfeit, but the grade would have been dropped from my GPA. I didn't know this. Not ever at school. I should have asked.
My first semester, I took accelerated Spanish, every morning at 7 a.m.. It got too hard, I fell behind, and I grew too anxious to keep going. If I had withdrawn, I would have maintained a B average and still had enough credits to keep my scholarship for another year.
The worst that I ever felt at college was the discovery that I had missed my economics exam by a day. Wrote it down wrong in my planner. I had been doing well, but there was no way to come back from that: I had definitely failed the class. I did not know I could withdraw. I fell apart because of this. Maybe I still would have dropped the ball on my other classes that semester, but maybe not. Maybe I could have pulled something good from the semester. Maybe avoided academic probation.
So many things fell apart because of that, because I fell apart.
Kissing Jon
A few days after Kevin dumped me before graduating and moving to Texas, I kissed Jon. I shouldn't have done it. I was rebounding and wanting to feel wanted. I don't know if I had feelings for Jon, but the timing of the kiss made a relationship impossible. I was heartbroken and terrified of being emotionally vulnerable. And then we both behaved badly after the breakup, burning bridges with abandon.
Maybe the kiss itself wasn't a problem. It was under the stars in the mountains in spring. Romantic, actually. But it should have just been a kiss, not a contract. I should have talked to him and been honest. I owed it to both of us. Maybe we would have kept being friends.
Part-time Semester
I was afraid of failing another semester and being kicked out of BYU, so I only went part time that next fall. I shouldn't have. I had already proven myself capable of doing well. But I was scared. As a result, I lost access to the perks of full-time students. I couldn't work on campus, I couldn't get free counseling, and I had to ride the bus two hours every day to a retail job in Orem. I should have trusted myself enough to stay and work it through.
And I definitely should have continued going to counseling, for as long as it was available to me.
Emailing Kevin
When Kevin dumped me in 2005, it was pretty permanent. The week before, we had gone for a walk, and he had brought up the number of kids I wanted. He couldn't imagine going above six. Well, okay, I could maybe compromise to six. He also mentioned that he would be in Texas and wondered could I even afford tuition. I reminded him that I was a resident of Texas and got in-state tuition. I realized after the fact, too long after, that he was trying to break up with me then; but he was trying to use reasons instead of feelings, and it wasn't working. He had to do it better a few days later. It blindsided me, because what I now know to be his awkward attempt at a break up, I had seen as an awkward attempt to feel out the future of the relationship. Were we going to talk about me following him to Texas, working toward marriage? I kept a rock from that walk to remember it. I was an idiot.
At the end of that summer, after months of silence, I sent him an email wishing him luck on his new job. It reopened communication between us. I was always the one to reach back out to Kevin after we broke up. Every time. It was never him. I'm not saying that I should never have spoken to Kevin again. And, of course, I'm glad for how things worked out in the end. But I should have had a little dignity. I should have exercised a little selfcare. I should not have been so eager to bring him back into my life, when I needed to get my shit together. To this day, I wonder if he ever would have reached out to me on his own. If he had, it would have made for a healthier relationship.
Had I been in counseling at the time, I'm sure my counselor would have talked me out of it. I should have been healing, not heeling. Setting and maintaining healthy boundaries.
Dating More
I should have dated more. As awkward as I was and will ever be, there were opportunities. Maybe I could have casually dated Jon, without a relationship. There were the window washer boys from work who asked me out. Maybe I could have encouraged Chris, instead of fearing Julie. Or flirted more with Aaron. Or said yes to Joe. Hell, even dating Danny was good for me at first. You know, until it wasn't. Yikes. Casual dating would have been good practice for me in building relationships, communicating feelings, building confidence, etc.
Then again, I tended to run away from those who showed an interest in me. As Groucho Marx said, "I don't care to belong to any club that will have me as a member." See also, why I was getting therapy.
Moving in with Nora
When Nora moved back to Provo to go back to school, she initially lived with Jason. But when he got engaged, she had to look elsewhere. She asked me to live with her off campus, so she could keep her cat and not have to have roommates. I love Nora, tons and tons, so this one is hard for me to admit. I should have said no.
Living in that house was expensive, twice what I was paying at the Riv in the summer. It was also very isolated and far from campus. I grew lonely and depressed. I, who struggled every time a friend left, should have known better than to move away from my roommates. Friendship was an obsession of mine. I needed my friends, and I knew it. I had been too lonely too long.
Have I mentioned that I shouldn't have quit therapy?
I should have stayed with Emilie, or moved with her to another apartment. I should have let Jason keep my furniture. I would have invited Nora to live with me, and that would have been great, but if not, there still would have been Sunday dinners with the family.
Moving to Texas
Another hard one to admit is that I should not have left school to move to Texas. I'm proud of myself for being so adventurous--what I did was brave--but it was also desperate. What I did wasn't necessarily the problem, but why I did it sure was.
Kevin had told me that he loved me. The afternoon waiting for the locksmith the day of Tarythe's wedding, and that night waiting outside her mom's house for others to arrive, had been emotionally intimate. Romantic. When Kevin came to Utah and told me he loved me, it felt lifechanging. However, then I returned to my lonely life in my isolated house. I wanted to escape, and I thought moving to him would mean something for our relationship, a future wherein I wouldn't be lonely and isolated.
I told him that I wanted to move, and he told me about Lori.
That I still went is incredibly pathetic. I should have finished the school year, at least, maybe gone to Austin for the summer, flying down instead of bringing a moving truck. The result to our relationship would have been the same, only he would have been too busy to see me for fewer months.
Not kissing Jared
Days after I broke up with Kevin in Austin, Jared took me to the movies. On the way into the theater, he pushed me up against the wall and leaned. Because of that damn movie Hitch, which was all the rage among our cohorts at the time, he did not kiss me. He just stared and waited. I froze, also waiting. I remembered Jon and how kissing him too soon had ruined our relationship, and I panicked about doing that to Jared. So I didn't. He eventually stepped back, and we watched the movie.
There were other opportunities, but that was the one I remember most. And regret. I honestly think it was a pivotal moment in my life, one of those rare moments where a single choice has a huge affect on subsequent events. I loved Jared, one of only two men I ever loved other than Kevin. If I had kissed him, something would have happened, though of course I don't know what.
I learned the wrong lesson from kissing Jon. I learned that I shouldn't let my emotions make me impulsive; but I should have learned honesty and emotional vulnerability. Even if I hadn't kissed Jared, I could have at least told him how I felt. I never did. Even when he later flew to Utah to see me, uncertainty stopped me from making a move.
Not moving back to Utah
After Kevin and I broke up, and I was left in Texas once again isolated and lonely, I should have gone back to school. My apartment contract ended at the right time, I was still enrolled for the fall; I could have gone back seamlessly. But it felt like giving up. I delayed another semester, which meant reapplying to school, having to sell my lease, moving in winter, etc.
I did manage to mend things with Kevin, but I still didn't see him except for Thanksgiving. I could have done the mending from the distance. Or seen if he would have made the effort himself. Thanksgiving was a nice romantic weekend. Kevin told me he wanted to marry me, though he immediately backtracked, clarifying that he wasn't actually proposing. It was a nice weekend, but we might have spent the holiday together even if I had returned to school. After all, I had flown out the previous year.
I should have limited my level of commitment to his. Let his behavior be my guide. I should have set healthy boundaries and prioritized my own needs during that time. I should have been in school and working on me. I should have taken the time to be selfish.
Graduating Early
I should have remained at least another semester at BYU, graduating in spring instead of December. I could have finished my economics minor or retaken more classes to up my GPA. I could have finished the Honors requirements. I should have taken time and lived deliberately. There were internships and travel abroad and so many other opportunities that I gave up by deciding to leave early. I had taken the GRE and done really well. I should have seen where that would have taken me.
Instead, I went back to Texas. When I asked Kevin if he was going to propose, he asked, "What, you mean right away?" And, no, it wasn't right away. It was nine months later. I should have stayed and finished strong. Given myself the chance to be the most important person in my life for a while. Then, I could have gone to Austin, if he still wanted me to.
There were so many ways that I could have done better in college my first time around, taken advantage of opportunities for growth and fulfillment. I should have had more confidence in myself back when I was young and immortal and the world was my oyster.
* For anyone concerned about the paradoxes or whatnot, obviously each of these is dependent upon all previous decisions having been made as they were in life. Each is an independent thought without conjecture regarding their effect on later decisions I've revisited.